The Ultimate Grassfed Steak Buying Guide

There’s nothing quite like a great steak cooked over a hot grill or cast-iron skillet. But with so many cuts to choose from, it can be hard to know which steak is right for your family, cooking style, or budget.

Here at Prairie Creek Pastures, our cattle are 100% grass-fed and grass-finished and raised on regenerative pastures without hormones, antibiotics, or vaccines. That means every cut delivers clean flavor, nutrient-dense nutrition, and the kind of quality you can feel good about feeding your family.

This guide walks through the steaks we offer and helps you understand what makes each one unique — from rich, buttery ribeyes to lean and flavorful sirloins.

Choosing the Right Steak

When picking a steak, most people care about four things:

• Flavor
• Tenderness
• Marbling
• Value

Some cuts excel in one area, while others strike a balance across all four.

Filet Mignon

The Most Tender Cut

Filet mignon is known for one thing above all else: tenderness.

Cut from the tenderloin, this steak has very little connective tissue, giving it an exceptionally soft texture.

What to Expect

• Extremely tender
• Lean and delicate
• Mild beef flavor
• Smaller portion size

Best Cooking Method

Cook carefully over high heat and avoid overcooking. Because filet is lean, medium-rare is ideal.

Cost: $$$

Great For

• Date nights
• Elegant dinners
• Anyone prioritizing tenderness

Ribeye Steak

The Classic Steakhouse Favorite

The ribeye is prized for its rich marbling and bold flavor. Cut from the rib section, this steak delivers the most traditional steakhouse experience and is often the first choice for serious steak lovers.

What to Expect 

• Rich, juicy flavor
• Excellent marbling
• Tender texture
• Best for grilling or cast iron searing

Best Cooking Method

Sear over high heat and finish at a more moderate temp. A simple seasoning of salt and pepper is often all you need.

Cost: $$

Great For

• Special occasions
• Reverse searing
• Grill enthusiasts

NY Strip Steak

Best All-Around Steak 

The New York Strip is a favorite for people who want a steak that balances tenderness with a firmer, beefier bite. It is a dependable steak that is easy to cook and hard to mess up.

Compared to a ribeye, the strip steak is slightly leaner but still offers excellent flavor and a satisfying texture.

What to Expect

• Bold beef flavor
• Moderate marbling
• Tender with a slight chew
• Consistent cooking results

Best Cooking Method

Excellent on the grill or pan-seared with butter and herbs.

Cost: $$

Great For

• Weeknight steaks
• Steak sandwiches
• First-time grass-fed buyers
  

Top Sirloin Steak

Lean, Affordable, and Versatile

Top sirloin is one of the best everyday steaks because it delivers great flavor at a more affordable price point.

It’s leaner than ribeye or ny strip steak but still tender when cooked correctly.

What to Expect

• Lean and hearty
• Great beef flavor
• Excellent value
• Easy to cook

Best Cooking Method

Grill or pan-sear to medium-rare and slice against the grain.

Cost: $

Great For

• Family dinners
• Meal prep
• Steak salads and bowls

Flat Iron Steak

One of the Best Values in Beef

Flat iron steak combines tenderness, marbling, and affordability in one underrated cut.

It’s cut from the shoulder and offers excellent flavor without the premium price tag of ribeye or filet.

What to Expect

• Tender texture
• Great marbling
• Rich flavor
• Excellent value

Best Cooking Method

Perfect for cast iron or grilling.

Cost: $

Great For

• Budget-friendly steak nights
• Sandwiches
• Slicing over salads

Hanger Steak

The Butcher’s Favorite

Hanger steak is one of the most flavorful cuts on the animal and remains a hidden gem for many home cooks.

It has deep beef flavor and a loose grain that absorbs marinades beautifully.

What to Expect

• Intense beef flavor
• Tender when sliced correctly
• Loose texture
• Excellent for marinades

Best Cooking Method

Cook quickly over high heat and always slice against the grain. These can be difficult to cook evenly because it tapers from thick to thin, but utilizing cool/hot parts of the grill can solve that.

Cost: $

Great For

• Steak tacos
• Fajitas
• Chimichurri-style preparations

Flank Steak

Lean and Full of Flavor

Flank steak is a long, lean cut with incredible flavor. While it’s not as naturally tender as ribeye or filet, proper slicing makes all the difference.

What to Expect

• Lean texture
• Strong beef flavor
• Best when marinated
• Great for slicing thin

Best Cooking Method

Marinate first, grill hot and fast, then slice thinly against the grain.

Cost: $

Great For

• Fajitas
• Stir fry
• Steak salads

Skirt Steak

Big Flavor for High-Heat Cooking

Skirt steak is famous for its rich flavor and fast cooking time. It’s thin, intensely beefy, and one of the best cuts for quick meals.

What to Expect

• Deep beef flavor
• Thin texture
• Quick cooking
• Excellent marinade absorption

Best Cooking Method

Cook hot and very fast. Watch these carefully as skirts are thin and can overcook quickly.

Cost: $

Great For

• Tacos
• Fajitas
• Quick grilling

Final Thoughts

The “best” steak ultimately depends on what you enjoy most.

• Love rich marbling? Go with the ribeye.
• Dependable all-around steak? New york strip.
  
• Want the most tender experience? Choose filet mignon.
• Looking for everyday value? Top sirloin and flat iron are hard to beat.
• Prefer bold beef flavor? Try hanger, flank, or skirt steak.

No matter which cut you choose, you can trust that every steak from Prairie Creek Pastures comes from cattle raised the way nature intended — on pasture, with clean nutrition and careful stewardship from start to finish. 

Simple Steps for Grilling Amazing Grassfed Steak

1.Salt & Pepper 1hr Before

Rub a generous amount of salt and pepper on all sides of the previously thawed steak and let set for around a hour. (you can still get pretty good results if you don't have time to let it set)

2. Use High Heat - Don’t Overcook It!

Most steaks benefit from a hot grill or cast-iron skillet to create a quick sear and then move to a slightly cooler spot on the grill to finish. Use a meat thermometer to gauge exactly when it's done. Rare 120°| medium 135°| medium-well 145°. Don't "ruin" your steaks by overcooking! Well-done tends to give you a dry texture and reduce the flavor. 

3. Let It Rest

Lightly cover and rest steaks for 5–10 minutes before slicing to give the fibers time to cool slightly and reabsorb the juices. 

4. Slice Against the Grain

Especially important for flank, skirt, and hanger steaks. 

It's really pretty simple and gives good results every time! For a more detailed explanation of these steps check out more info from our farmer friends, the Shanks.